Becoming a teacher of writing: Primary student teachers reviewing their relationship with writing. English in Education , 48, — Englund, T. Nordic Studies in Education , 36, — Academic Tribes and Territories: Intellectual enquiry and the culture of disciplines 2nd ed. Stockholm Studies in Scandinavian Philology Graue, Graue, E. Writing in education research. Serlin Eds. According to Becher and Trowler Becher, T.
Soft science, in turn, is often linked to humanities and social sciences and the use of pluralistic and interpretative approaches to understand social phenomena. This means that writing in different disciplines has differing epistemological assumptions and goals. Differences in academic writing have also been captured in studies based on an academic literacies approach. Student writing in higher education: An academic literacies approach. Studies in Higher Education , 23, — The academic literacies tradition emphasizes academic writing as a social and cultural practice in higher education cf.
Amsterdam : John Benjamins. Negotiating the territory of tertiary literacies: A case study of teacher education.
A teacher's dream brought to life | World Vision International
Linguistics and Education , 17, — In contrast to research that considers academic writing as a predefined set of rules that student teachers need to adapt to, an academic literacies approach focuses on writing as a social practice in which students take part in, and develop, different literacies. Legitimate peripheral participation. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press. However, a social practice in itself cannot be regarded as a natural domain.
Teaching First-Year Students | Center for Teaching | Vanderbilt University
Discourses of writing and learning to write. Language and Education , 18, — Writing ideals captures the requirements placed on writing by teachers and students in different disciplines cf. The term writing ideal has in addition been useful in understanding the influence of the social and cultural process in higher education, as the ideals of writing are constituted in practice by those involved. Street, Street, B. Real language series. Longman : London. When student teachers enter higher education, they successively come into contact with different disciplines.
Search for your next international school job
In this article, we follow the timeline at the specific university concerned, where the students start with 1 educational science, a discipline which the two teacher programmes have in common in their first semester. Subsequently, we separate the two programmes. First, we present the results from disciplines studied in preschool teacher education: 2 natural science and 3 aesthetic studies. Secondly, we present results from disciplines studied as part of secondary school teacher education: 4 social science and 5 history. Teacher education programmes included in the study — the first two years.
In the selection process, we contacted two groups of students, informed them about the research project and asked them if they wished to participate. As a result, we were able to follow eight student teachers specializing in preschool early years education. In the upper secondary group with social science as their main subject , only one student was interested in taking part in the interview study. We therefore contacted another group of students on the upper secondary programme with history as their main subject as a complement to the study, which resulted in the participating of another two students in the study.
In the preschool group, all the students studying to become preschool teachers were women. By comparison, of those studying to become upper secondary school teachers of social science or history, twenty-two out of a total of twenty-four students were men, as were all three of those participating in the study. We can conclude that there is a gender difference in our data. How this may have influenced the outcome of the study, however, is hard to draw any conclusions about, since it has not been a focus of data collection and analysis.
Space and ethical considerations do not permit contextualization or biographical details, but awareness of context remains a significant element of the interpretative process in the analysis. To protect the privacy of interviewees, they have been given fictitious names.
Before moving on to the analysis, we provide a brief outline of the student teachers who took part in the interview study. Participants in the interview study. Wibeck, Wibeck, V. Lund : Studentlitteratur. Den kvalitativa forskningsintervjun [The qualitative research interview]. This made it possible to ask both general and specific questions about their experiences of academic writing. The interviews were conducted, transcribed and analysed by one of the researchers. The analytical process consisted of two steps.
The Pros and Cons of Teaching Abroad
In the first, the empirical data was coded to capture passages in which the students talked about their experiences of writing ideals in practice in instruction, in their own writing and in feedback in different disciplines during their teacher education. Through this procedure, the analysis focused on academic writing as a practice in higher education cf.
London : Sage Publications. This means that the content and language used to describe writing ideals in different disciplines are the subject of a multilayered analysis, moving between theory, analytical concepts and what emerged from the interviews. At the same time, we are well aware that other actors and contexts could complement the study. It is important to emphasize that these results are to be understood in relation to a specific context, and that academic disciplines are historically constituted.
Educational science is the first discipline the students come into contact with during their education, both preschool and secondary school student teachers at the university in question. The criteria for perspective writing seem to encompass both content discussing an issue from different angles and form being able to present an argument in a convincing way.
According to the students, teacher educators emphasize that both textual and formal structures are required to develop a coherent line of argument. Journal of English for Academic Purposes , 11, 26 — In terms of content, the discipline makes use of references from, for example, different learning theories behaviourism, cognitivism, sociocultural theory, and pragmatism to get the students to reflect on different approaches to learning and teaching.
In terms of form, the student teachers express the view that there is a strong emphasis on how to structure a text and how to make references. In the following quotation, a student on the preschool teacher programme describes how she perceives the demands placed on writing during the first semester. Example 1: Write in order to understand writing Josephine : This is how we do it here. If you understand this model you can better adapt to other places.
The idea was not to write right or wrong, but rather to understand how to construct writing so you can use it in the future.
That is what they often told us: it is important that you write in order to understand writing. You need to have a start, a focus in the middle and a conclusion that links back to the beginning. And it is important to have research questions. Often they highlighted that these can change during the writing process because you need to find a focus. In her reflection on writing, Josephine accepts the culture and tradition of the discipline.
She also indicates that she has started to comply and identify with this academic genre by claiming that this is how we do it here. Interestingly, Josephine reflects upon this learning experience in relation to future writing. However, there is no indication in the quotation of whether this is pointing forward to their future professional role.
What is evident, though, is that she has grasped that writing is an important means of learning cf.
- Learn more about Participate Learning’s application and get started today.?
- Cons of teaching abroad.
- International School!
Wingate, Wingate, U. It is also clear that Josephine has learnt the academic genre when she describes how a text should be created and structured in educational science, emphasizing for example that in this disciplinary culture a text requires a main thread, which means that different parts of it need to be linked together.
For Josephine, the experience of academic writing in educational science is positive, and she finds writing in higher education inspiring. But for most of the student teachers interviewed, this type of academic writing in educational science during the first semester is recalled as a major struggle. And for some of them the new requirements were not in line with their expectations:. Example 2: It was very difficult Caroline : It was very broad and difficult to grasp to begin with. They were very, very difficult texts for.
I felt the same; we come from a similar background and have worked before.